Wednesday, April 28, 2010 - 2:02 PM

There are several fascinating elections due this year. Next month, we can look forward to Britain's most unpredictable outcome in 100 years. In Poland, former Prime Minister Jaroslaw Kaczynski has become a presidential candidate in hopes of succeeding his twin brother Lech, killed in a plane crash earlier this month. Japan's ruling DPJ faces a referendum on its first turbulent months in power with upper house elections this summer. In November, recession-weary Americans will go to the polls to elect a new congress.
With all that going on, you probably haven't thought much about next month's local elections in North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany's largest state. Eager to institutionalize a post-bailout era of greater fiscal discipline, the German government is preparing to push for a major revision of eurozone rules in the form of a new European Union treaty. The aim is to build momentum behind a drive for fiscal consolidation and greater powers to enforce rules across the currency union.
But it's hard to imagine that Chancellor Angela Merkel's government will get what it wants. Irreconcilable differences remain among key European states, and Germany doesn't have the political power it held a generation ago in the run-up to introduction of the euro. Today's union is much larger, and the perceived benefits of convergence are worth less. The contentious debate over a new treaty will unfold just as the battle is heating up to replace Jean-Claude Trichet as president of Europe's Central Bank.
The immediate concern is that Standard & Poor's lowered Greece's debt rating to junk on Tuesday and Portugal by two steps. The big longer-term worry for Europe is that politicians locked into tough deflationary programs (in Greece and beyond) will take the once-taboo step of pushing for debt restructuring. We're not talking about the break-up of the eurozone, no matter how much apocalyptic rhetoric we hear in days to come or how many pundits write articles this fall with titles like "Who killed Europe?" But the less dramatic risks for European fiscal policy are plenty serious.
That's where Germany's local elections come in. The balloting in North Rhine-Westphalia, home to more than 20 percent of Germany's citizens, will provide a real test of Angela Merkel's center-right government. A bad result would jeopardize Germany's shot at tax reform. More to the point, it would weaken the entire eurozone by undermining support for fiscal discipline at the heart of Europe.
A return of the German left, even a modest one, will generate much more expansionary policy than we saw during the grand coalition period between 2005 and 2009. That will create stronger institutional support for German labor demands, driving a rebalancing within the eurozone as German labor costs begin to rise. That will undermine European competitiveness at a delicate moment in the union's recovery from recession. Over the longer term, it's hard to imagine Europe's fiscal woes improving in that environment. That's why I believe strongly in the eurozone, but not in a strong eurozone.
Ian Bremmer is president of Eurasia Group and author of The End of the Free Market: Who Wins the War Between States and Corporations? (Portfolio, May 2010)
AXEL SCHMIDT/AFP/Getty Images
The local elections matter, but not how you think
Most pundits would agree that Merkel was trying to keep the Greece issue of the agenda in the run-up to the elections in North Rhine-Westphalia. Since this is no longer possible, you're right to ask what the implications for Germany are.
From a German perspective, I believe that you overestimate the likelihood of fundamental changes in Germany's policies if Merkel's conservative party will lose the election because of Greece.
Germany's fundamental economic data are pointing in the right direction. Unemployment figures - which were released today - say that unemployment has been reduced to 8.1%. Also, polls show that the Left party - Socialists from the GDR and disappointed Social Democrats and Unionists - will struggle to get into the Parliament in North Rhine-Westphalia - they cannot capitalise from the crisis.
Thus, there is only little support for the policies that you describe in the last paragraph of your blog post. A bad election result for Merkel's coalition of Conservatives and Liberals in North Rhine-Westphalia will, however, have negative domestic implications for the Chancellor. Her coalition would lose the majority in the Bundestag, a Federal body that represents the Federal States and that is essential for any major reforms in Germany.
If Merkel's party will lose in the elections, Germany will actually be less influential on the international stage because Merkel will have even more problems to organise a majority for her policies at home. But Germany will not become more "socialist".
The Call, from Ian Bremmer, uses cutting-edge political science to predict the political future -- and how it will shape the global economy.
Read More
(1)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE